Judging Criteria

The International Jury selects and awards a winning article, photograph and video in each age category, as well as a runner up, or runners up. 

Judges may assign a score of 0-5 based on how well the submission meets five further criteria. Points are: Excellent - 5 points, Very well - 4 points, Well - 3 points, Fairly Well - 2 points, Qualified - 1 point and if it does not qualify - 0 points. Participants are encouraged to meet as many of these additional criteria as possible, to improve their work and chances of winning. It is not, however, compulsory to meet these criteria. 

 

Composition i.e. form, structure, and quality

  • The submission has to be well structured and, in the case of articles and videos, cover who, what, where, why, when, and how.
  • The article or video has to have a beginning, middle, and end.
  • In the case of photographs and video, the picture/video technically and artistically has to be well done i.e. well composed, of high quality, and impact.

 

Fair, balanced, and objective reporting

  • The piece (article or video) has to be balanced and fair in terms of representing different sides of an argument prior to offering a suggestion for potential solution.
  • The quotes used have to be from real, credible, sources.
  • Scientific or statistical reporting has to be accurate and supported by sources/ footnotes.
  • The photograph or video is a fair representation, and the subject or audience has not been manipulated. Editorial alternations to photos or video (including but not limited to colour, contrast, definition, shadows, highlights, cropping, levelling, etc.) are permissible, as long as these alternations do NOT alter the reality of the subject or object of the photo/video.

 

Informative and well researched

  • The submission has to cover relevant historical, economic, social and/or political implications and possible consequences.
  • It has to make a link to the bigger global picture.
  • The solution presented has to be thoroughly explained, well argued and justified.
  • The use of illustrations, pictures, supporting paragraphs, subtitles, etc., has to be thought through.

 

Originality, style, and independence  

  • The piece is original in its scope or style i.e. the participant has picked a challenging topic or created an innovative or moving piece.
  • The participants have to leave the school grounds i.e. engage in field work and interview people in person as well as on the telephone, not just use or quote online sources.

 

Dissemination

  • Dissemination through minimum three media outlets/events including internal school channels.
  • Participants need to state the dissemination (genre of media outlet etc) that has been done.

 

In addition

The Jury is at liberty not to award in the case of too few submissions and to give more than one award in the case of exceptional entries in one or more age categories. The Jury will also give points to journalistic and environmental aspects of the submissions based on their professional backgrounds. It will be scored from 0-3 points.